Sicilian-Italian · $$$

Sicily Osteria

Name: Sicily Osteria
Address: 328-330 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, USA, New York, United States
Price range: $$$

$65/person

Reserve ahead · busy weekdays

Sicilian-Italian · $$$

Sicily Osteria

$65/person

Reserve ahead · busy weekdays

Manhattan

What to Order

15 dishes

How these rank in New York

See every restaurant ranked for a dish, not just this one.

All best dishes in New York

Our Take

Reliable Sicilian-Italian in the Theater District

Based on 3,183 reviews

consistent pasta qualitywarm atmosphereefficient pre-theater service

midtown pricing premiumcan feel rushed during theater hours

Best for: Pre-theater diners needing a reliable, fast-enough meal before an 8pm curtain
Date nights looking for a warm, unfussy Italian backdrop
Groups celebrating with Italian staples and a long wine list
Out-of-towners who want a solid Italian meal near Times Square without the tourist-trap feel
Busiest: Weekday dinner (6-7:30pm, pre-theater rush)

Reviews

See all reviews

Change city

Want a ping when these happen?

Want a ping when these happen?

Sicily Osteria

Want a ping when these happen?

Want a ping when these happen?

Get directions

Want a ping when these happen?

Want a ping when these happen?

Sicily Osteria

Want a ping when these happen?

Want a ping when these happen?

Get directions

Want a ping when these happen?

Want a ping when these happen?

What to Order

All dishes · Sicily Osteria

How these rank in New York

Our Take

Reliable Sicilian-Italian in the Theater District

Reviews

Atmosphere

Questions & Answers

Ask about Sicily Osteria

Questions about Sicily Osteria

Menu

Delete photo?

Report info for Sicily Osteria