Change city

Rankings Search My Lists Download

Best dishes
About
Support
Privacy
Terms

Morel. Eat with friends.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Sammy's Fish Box Menu: What to Order in City Island | Morel

Sammy's Fish Box

City Island

Sammy's Fish Box

American Seafood · $$$

Sammy's Fish Box

About this score

★★★★★★★★★★3.23Early score

The Morel score blends thousands of public reviews from across the web with ratings from Morel diners. As diners here weigh in, their ratings take the lead.

Public reviews from across the webIncluded

Morel diner ratingsNone yet

This spot doesn't have Morel ratings yet — be the first.

$55/person

Often a waitReserve ahead · busy weekends

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Good to know

Get directions

Sammy's Fish Box

What to Order

7 dishes

Combination Platter
Combination Platter
$109
Twin Lobsters
Twin Lobsters
$65
Tropical Cocktails
Tropical Cocktails
Whole Maine Lobster
Whole Maine Lobster
$60
P.E.I. Mussels
P.E.I. Mussels
$30
Chilled Whole Maine Lobster
Chilled Whole Maine Lobster
$30
Hennessy Colada
Hennessy Colada
$22

All dishes · Sammy's Fish Box

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

How these rank in New York

See every restaurant ranked for a dish, not just this one.

Best Combination Platter in New York

All best dishes in New York

Our Take

Iconic City Island seafood institution since 1966

Based on 10,734 reviews

generous portionsold-school NYC vibefun for groups

long waits in summertourist pricing

Best for: Large family dinners or birthday celebrations (group-friendly)
Summer weekend outings with out-of-town visitors
Anyone craving classic American fried/broiled seafood with a view
Busiest: Summer weekend dinner (5-9pm)
Reservations: Recommended

Reviews

See all reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask about Sammy's Fish Box

Ask anything — about dishes, dietary options, ambiance, or reservations.

200 characters remaining

Questions about Sammy's Fish Box

Menu

No menu photos yet — help others by sharing one.

Delete photo?

This menu photo will be removed for everyone. This can't be undone.

Report info for Sammy's Fish Box

What's wrong?What should it say? (optional)More context (optional)0/500