Change city

Rankings SearchMy ListsDownload

Best dishes
About
Support
Privacy
Terms

Morel. Eat with friends.

Home
Search
Map
Rankings
Crews
Notifications
Find friends

About · Support · Privacy · Terms
Morel. Eat with friends.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

City Island Pizza Company Menu: What to Order | Morel

City Island Pizza Company

City Island

New York
›
City Island

City Island Pizza Company

Italian · $$

City Island Pizza Company

$25/person

Reserve ahead

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Good to know

Get directions

City Island Pizza Company

Google4.8(94 reviews)

Reserve a table Website

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

Want a ping when these happen?

Turn on notifications to catch follows, likes, and new check-ins the moment they happen.

What to Order

16 dishes

Rice Balls
Rice Balls
Fried risotto balls with fillings
$14
Clam Bar Pizza
Clam Bar Pizza
Pizza topped with fresh clams
$28
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Large Pizza
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Large Pizza
$25
Sunday Supper
Sunday Supper
$25
Lobster Roll
Lobster Roll
Butter-poached lobster on a roll
$36
Grilled Octopus
Grilled Octopus
$22
Red Hot Chili Pepper Pie
Red Hot Chili Pepper Pie
Pizza with n'duja and sausage
$22
Chicken Parm with Linguine
Chicken Parm with Linguine
$22
Carbonara
Carbonara
$22
Brussels Sprouts with Pepperoni
Brussels Sprouts with Pepperoni
$12
Linguini White Clam Sauce
Linguini White Clam Sauce
$24
Bone-in Pork Chop
Bone-in Pork Chop
$28
14oz. Prime New York Strip Steak
14oz. Prime New York Strip Steak
$36
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
$15
Baked Clams
Baked Clams
$14
Nutella Hot Chocolate
Nutella Hot Chocolate
$5

All dishes · City Island Pizza Company

How these rank in New York

See every restaurant ranked for a dish, not just this one.

Best Rice Balls in New York
Best Sunday Supper in New York
Best Lobster Roll in New York
Best Grilled Octopus in New York
Best Carbonara in New York
Best Crispy Brussels Sprouts in New York

All best dishes in New York

Our Take

Coastal Italian spot serving artisan pizzas and house-made pasta

Based on 94 reviews

excellent rice ballswarm hospitalityhigh-quality ingredients

Best for: Casual family dinners
Weekend outings to City Island
Groups looking for a high-value Sunday Supper

Reviews

See all reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask about City Island Pizza Company

Ask anything — about dishes, dietary options, ambiance, or reservations.

200 characters remaining

Questions about City Island Pizza Company

Menu

No menu photos yet — help others by sharing one.

Delete photo?

This menu photo will be removed for everyone. This can't be undone.

Report info for City Island Pizza Company

What's wrong?What should it say? (optional)More context (optional)0/500